Title: And I Must Scream
Pairing: Erik Lehnsherr/Charles Xavier
Summary: Silent Hill AU. Erik knew that coming back to this town was a pointless venture, but Charles’s cryptic letter and the faint hope that his death was nothing more than a trick are enough to keep him moving forward.
Warnings: Graphic depictions of violence, major character death
Criteria: Underrated fic
Review: I am honestly obsessed with this story, and have no idea why it hasn’t gotten more attention! It’s incredibly creepy, the build of suspense is absolutely perfect, and my heart was left pounding out of my chest by the end. Truly amazing.